Classical Music
Piracy as it affects “serious” songwriters and composers
Jul 1st
Recently after reading the blog of my friend, John Mackey (one of the most talented young composers for band I have ever known) I learned of the plight that so many composers and songwriters go through facing internet piracy. So often, because of the size and bulldog tactics of the R.I.A.A. we think of piracy only in terms of lost CD sales and missing download revenue. There is an entirely different side of the coin. The writers and composers of the music contained therein are also missing their monies derived from these sales… this is a quite unfortunate by-product of the loss of recorded music sales. Even more disturbing though is the growth of sheet music “sharing” sites that facilitate the piracy of their actual written work. Not being a composer or publisher myself, this is an area of the business I hadn’t thought of in terms of piracy, but it deserves equal ground with the chest pounding and lawsuit wielding recorded music battle for legal downloads and sales.
John mentioned a composer he likes named Jason Robert Brown. I personally had not heard of him, but that rarely means much in the musical world. After going to Jason’s blog, I find a most fascinating account of his back and forth with an infringer! Imagine that, rather than suing her… he spoke to her… tried to educate her… (some people are beyond education). This was a really unique approach to dealing with piracy. tackling it one person at a time. Imagine if Metallica had called on a few pirates back in 2002… WOW what a news story that would have been… anyways I digress. I continued reading the rest of this back and forth and becomes quickly apparent that she might be beyond education… the point though is he reached out to her and a number of other infringers and simply explained that he makes a living off of his music and politely asked them to stop sharing… and many of them did!!!! Reading his story also led me to his wife’s blog. She is fighting the same fight as a composer and from what I can tell has been a bit more outspoken on the subject. I think this is GREAT. More composers need to get involved in “the good fight”. I have said for years but educating the general public is the key to thwarting this habit of stealing our intellectual property.
To do my part, I have done some searching and below is a list of LEGAL / PAID download sites to acquire sheet music. Do your part.
Taco Taco! Texas Music Educators recap
Apr 23rd
Ok Folks,
I am sorry.
I am the worst Blogger ever! But in my defense, this has been a busy spring. My next blog post will illuminate you as to what I have been up to… I originally typed this February 17 and forgot to post it… so here it is!!!
I just returned from the Texas Music Educators Association convention (TMEA)- or to the uninitiated… the “everybody who matters and has anything of value for the world or music education” convention.
All I can say is WOW! This was my first TMEA even though I am quite the legacy. My Frandfather was President of TMEA in the 1950s!
TMEA is by all accounts much larger than TBA (Texas Bandmasters Association)- or any other conference I attend on Music Education for that matter. Overall, despite a lousy economy the attendance was really quite good. Many of my friends from education land were there and the overall picture I got from the state of budgets (at least in TX) was that most were actually doing alright (take a note California). If Texans know how to do anything- it is play football and field a marching band- both of which they fund mightily.
TMEA was not only a time for me to catch up with my buddies, but also a great time to meet up with old and new clients to discuss current and future projects. I decided rather than delivering a list of my clients as a recap, I would make a photo montage of them and spent one afternoon taking photos of their booths, products, etc. These photos are on our Naxos Music Library facebook page here. Other clients in attendance were Alfred Music Publishing, Hal Leonard, Ivasi, SmartMusic, Professor Carol, and a few I cant seem to remember.
All In All this was a GREAT conference. The weather did not cooperate as it rained much of the time we were there and it was quite cold, however we made the best of it by imbibing in great Mexican food and our fair share of Margaritas. Hopefully next year the weather will be better as this is going on my Educational conference list permanently.
Til next time, Over and Out!
Making your way as the “conductor” of your success
Oct 7th
Today as I read my daily liturgy of various blogs and blog posts I stumbled upon a short statement brought forth on Hypebot.
“Raise Your Baton” was the title of this post. This struck me on a number of levels as both a musician, lover of classical music, business person, and last but not least… the son of a conductor (not train, but music).
In this short post he spoke of the vast amount of resources available and the ease at which one can enter the business community these days whether it be as a record label, publisher, artist, or tech startup. He goes on to surmise that trying to do it all yourself will drive you nuts and the smartest of entrepreneurs should surround themselves with capable people who can help achieve and accomplish the task at hand. The smartest entrepreneur will raise their baton and become the conductor of the project.
This analogy is really great. Some of the people I respect most in this world were the ones willing to admit they didn’t know how to do everything. One such person always used to say- “I don’t know how to do everything… that’s why I surround myself with experts like youself (moi?)… who do.” Until now I always took this sentiment to be nothing more than a nice statement.. but in fact he is right. He IS the conductor. You see, as Bruce Houghton points out- the conductor doesn’t know how to play every instrument in the orchestra… but he(she) does know how to read music and he knows what the symphony should sound like. The source of my admiration IS the conductor of his business and it’s success.
So how do you become the conductor? Bruce accurately puts it as this… ” Start by learning your business. Assemble the players. Then raise your baton.” How simple… and perfect! Music to my ears.
New Developments
Jul 28th
It has been a busy summer! I have enjoyed my fair share of boating trips, business travel and just plain summer fun. While I have been hard at work and play, I have also been working on a few things in the interwebs.
So for my 9-5 (more like 6:30am – 11:00pm) I have been tossing around the idea of starting a licensing-centric blog. DUH- I already have one of those- but this would be a more refined, professional concoction of randomness than the fine blog you are currently reading. This would be a kinder, gentler blog. (well, right now- it’s more like a blog-ette) This blog would be centered on the licensing of music… specifically Classical music, but not confined to the genre specifically. There will ultimately be a great deal of cross-posting as many of the topics I cover there will be of interest to Is This Binding. Plus I have high hopes that having another presence in the blogosphere will help drive traffic to my other muse, NaxosLicensing.com . that site is still under construction- but will ultimately be a one-stop destination for licensing Classical, World and Jazz music for film, TV, advertising, etc.
I am also quite proud to say that the Naxos Music Library- the product for which I was originally hired at Naxos has now officially come of age. In just 5 years it now features more than 500,000 tracks (that’s a HALF MILLION- people!!!) of Classical, Jazz, Folk, World, Jazz, and Rock music… a virtual college music library/public library music collection! In that time- we have also managed to make sure that this service has matriculated to the very top research institutions in the world! Basically every major University you can name is a subscriber and a great deal of public libraries are as well. It is now utilized in more than 28 different countries! <proud papa moment> If you havent ever checked it out- be sure to go take a look… there is free trial access available… take it for a test-drive.
Ok- that’s all for now… Til next time
Yo Ho, Yo Ho a Pirate’s Life for me (not really)
Apr 20th
AAARGH!
So just in case you have been under a rock for the last 5 days, the ruling is in… the founders of Pirate Bay have been found guilty in a Swedish court of law. They have all been sentenced to one year in prison and will have to pay approximately $3 Million in damages (after the appeals process- if the ruling stands).
So what now?
The facilitators have been stopped, but what does that mean for all of the users (Pirates) populating Pirate Bay? What does this mean for the bay? Will it suddenly dry up? No. In a word… No. This really means nothing. The Swedish courts have placed their finger in the dyke… they have stopped the spillage for a moment, but the flood waters will remain. The Pirate Bay remains active… servers housed safely outside of Sweden… and the pirates sail on.
There is a lot of debate going on over whether the founders of TPB were injustly convicted… whether the ISPs should be held responsible as well. I think there are a lot of people at fault here including all named previously and in some way, I would love to see them held responsible. However, I am a realist. I understand that the times are changing and our industry needs to find better ways of making a living (outside of suing). Ultimately, the results of the pending appeals will leave a legacy of rulings that will affect the way our courts view file sharing for years to come. The next few years will no doubt be an interesting lot… time will tell.
As a sideline to this story, there has been a recent study stating that “pirates” are 10 times more likely to buy online music than law-abiding non-pirates. The number of participants in the study was rather small (less than2000), but I find it quite interesting and wonder if this is in fact the way it is… according to the comments below the story- the pirates doubt it as well.
Top 10 best ideas in Classical Music- a review
Mar 26th
Sorry for the feast and famine blog posts, but I am especially motivated this week. I was delighted when a colleague sent me a link to a new classical music blog (well at least new to me).
This blog, “The Dutch Perspective” written by Marc Van Bree is a refreshing take on cultural affairs and PR from the perspective of a non-profit PR and social media specialist. Not only did the title of his latest blog post excite me, but the content was quite exciting as well. The title, “The ten best ideas in classical music online” says it all, but as I read his David Letterman top 10 list, I realized that I (moreover Naxos) have much to do with several of the initiatives mentioned in the list.
If you are curious about the whole list, please feel free to read it and Marc’s other posts here.
I will spare you the details and go into the movements and initiatives that I/we had something to do with.
Baltimore Symphony Orchestra gives away memberships to Naxos Music Library with subscriptions to the new season
“The BSO enthusiastically proclaims “Imagine leaving a concert and wanting to go right home and hear your favorite parts of the music again and again…Well now you can!” on its Web site. And rightly so. This is a perfect example of a smart collaboration that adds value to the orchestra experience.” ## That’s right folks. We did it! We are partnering with not only the BSO, but a slew of other great Symphonies to offer the highly acclaimed Naxos Music Library as a value-add to season tickets purchases. The opportunity to work with these great orchestras offering this value for their subscribers has been a wonderful experience. Hopefully more will jump on board for next season!
Keeping Score / Beyond the Score
“Although they have distinct differences, I would put the San Francisco Symphony’s Keeping Score programs and the Chicago Symphony’s Beyond the Score programs in the same category of innovation. If it wasn’t for the negative connotations, I would be tempted to use the term “infotainment” to describe the presentations. Check them out and see how you would describe them.” ## While I have nothing to do with the beyond the score project (which I think is a phenomenal endeavor), I have worked with the good folks at the San Francisco Symphony on their initiative for a few years now providing licensed music for their educational CDs and am glad that their series is garnering recognition.
Classical music on Twitter (Toronto Symphony, Aspen Music Festival, London Symphony, Atlanta Symphony)
## Along with these great Symphonies, Naxos also has several Twitter accounts. We have found that these are a great way to connect with our customer base. In case you were wondering, you can follow the official Naxos Twitter account, Naxos Direct, Naxos Music Library account, or my personal account.
I think it’s pretty exciting that we are involved with 3 out of 10 of these initiatives. I enjoy being a part of a forward-thinking leader in the Classical Music World. That’s all for now.
Barack Obama- Classical Music Lover / Extraordinaire
Jan 16th
Ok, I am going to say it loud and proud. I VOTED FOR OBAMA! I have a number of reasons why I supported his campaign and most of which I will not share with you, but on the subject of the Arts, Arts in Education, and Music advocacy I am extremely outspoken!! I think this President and his administration is going to do great things for the Arts and below is just and example… just the start if you will. No matter what your political affiliations are, I think we can all agree that this will be a very cool musical collaboration…
If you read Variety (like I do- daily) you may or may have not seen this story, but at next week’s Inauguration, in the main entertainment slot, our incoming president is featuring the music of none other than John Williams! Performed by a quartet made up of Itzhak Perlman, Yo-Yo Ma, Anthony McGill (a clarinetist from the Met), and Gabriela Montero (a Venezuelan pianist). The music to be performed will be a new setting and Williams-esque take on Simple Gifts, the same music used thematically throughout Appalachian Spring, written by Aaron Copland (one of Obama’s favorite composers).
This is important to me for a few reasons.
- This administration IS going to support the Arts! Many other presidents have had Classical music performed at their inauguration, but to my recollection, none have ever commissioned a new work for the occasion.
- Aaron Copland and John Williams happen to be two of my Top 5 American composers. This has little relevance on you, the reader, but warms my heart.
- As stated in the article, Copland’s work was supposed to be performed at another Presidential Inauguration. Dwight D Eisenhower was set to have “Lincoln Portrait” performed at his inauguration, but the performance was cancelled at the last minute as Copland was accused of being a communist by Senator Joe McCarthy. Finally Copland will get his just spotlight at these festivities. Even if it is only a piece paying tribute to him, I think it is a fitting tribute and an important moment for American Classical music.
On a side note, Lincoln Portrait is set to be released on Naxos Records twice in the next 6 months. Once in It’s original Orchestral Form performed by the Nashville Symphony under the baton of Leonard Slatkin (released in February 2009 Naxos 8.559373-74) and again as part of my Naxos Wind Band Classics series in it’s Concert Band setting performed by the fine University of Missouri Wind Ensemble conducted by Dr. Tom O’Neal and Narrated by Alvin Chea of “Take 6″ fame (released in May 2009 Naxos Wind Band Classics 8.572108)
New Naxos Licensing site now available in Beta
Nov 20th
That’s right, folks… Now you can access the greatest collection of Classical Music available for Licensing through the World’s Leading Classical Label, Naxos!
It is my pleasure to introduce you to www.NaxosLicensing.com . A one-stop licensing resource featuring not only Naxos, but music from more than a dozen other labels that can be licensed easily. The vast majority of the music included at Naxos Licensing is one-stop licensing due to the fact that it is primarily Classical Music and in the Public Domain!!! There is plenty of modern music as well… Pretty much every great “classical” piece ever recorded.
This is still in Beta, so please feel free to try it out and let me know your thoughts/comments. Our goal is to have this be the premier licensing resource for Classical Music.
Go ahead give it a try…
Licensing 101 – a step-by-step guide to music licensing for film
Oct 20th
By Randall Foster, Licensing Manager, Naxos of America, Inc.
Music licensing for film can be a daunting task and is an often overlooked final item that gives most filmmakers and producers fits. The truth of the matter is music licensing is a relatively easy task if you go about it in the right way.
First off, I’d like to dispel a few common myths about music usage. ANY music included in your film requires the prior written permission of the copyright owner. There is no such thing as an accepted minimum use or using up to 30 seconds of a track of music. ANY usage without prior approval is illegal. The only exception being recordings that are considered “Public Domain†(any recording produced prior to 1923). These will of course be on wax cylinders and 78 RPM vinyl, so quality could be an issue here. Thus, basically ALL recordings require permission.
Another valid point that needs to be considered is the fact that for most contemporary music, there are two rights involved. The copyright for a recording is split between the owner of the sound recordings (the record label) and the owners of the underlying music (publishers). Like sound recordings, the same applies with regards to Public Domain works in publishing. In almost all cases, you can use underlying music written prior to 1923 without the consent of the publisher as it is deemed to be in the Public Domain. If it happens to be an old tune that has been arranged and re-issued, you will however need permission. The best place to get this information is to take it from the liner notes of whatever recording you are wishing to use. Most commercial recordings give publisher and writer credits and obviously, you will want to contact the record label that released the recording in question for the Master Use License (sound recording permissions). To be sure you are contacting the right entities it is best to do some additional research regarding the work…
A few great sources for this information are:
http://www.Copyright.gov – The official site of the US Copyright office
http://www.BMI.com – Performance Royalty Organization that features an easy to search listing of works
http://www.Ascap.com – Performance Royalty Organization that features an easy to search listing of works
http://www.HarryFox.com – Mechanical Royalty organization featuring a search as well
So I have figured out who to contact but how do I get permission?
Once you have acquired the appropriate information, you will need to submit a request for permission to the rights-holders of the Sound Recording (record label) and Underlying Copyrights (publisher(s)). The best way to submit this is via a formal request letter and personally speaking, an email is always appreciated over it’s slower predecessor. In the letter you will want to give all pertinent details of the film project including a brief synopsis, the name, address and contact info of your production company, overall budget, rights sought ( i.e. film-festivals only [cheaper!!], film festival and tv, All Media- World-wide – Perpetual rights [most expensive], or a tiered license with “options†you can exercise at a later date for those large rights). If at all possible, propose a reasonable price that you are willing to pay for the music. This will help the licensor immensely as they deliberate your situation. Master Use licenses fluctuate greatly from “free†to multiple thousands of dollars. Typically, the licensor will have a number in mind depending on the size of the project and the usage of the music, but it is always nice to make a fair offer. In many cases, you can get good background music at one-stop music licensing houses. These include a bevy of professional companies featuring “stock†background music… another option is to go with Classical music as the majority of it is in the Public domain. On average, 8 out of 10 Master Use Licenses we issue are essentially “all-in†as there are no rights to be obtained for Mozart, or Bach’s compositions.
Your request should follow the guidelines below…
1. Give a summary of your project, a description of where and how exactly will the work be used (e.g. title theme, background music, the climax scene, over the closing credits, etc.) and the media rights you want (e.g. film festivals, broadcasting theaters, Website, Radio/TV commercials, audio tours, etc.)
2. If your license request is for a video production, consumer product (e.g. video games, compilation CD’s, Corporate promotional CD’s) is important that you tell us the number of units you plan to manufactured.
3. Also, to easily identify the work you are interested in, use the catalog number or any criteria relevant to the work. Here are some other very useful criteria you should us: Title(s) and duration of music, Composer, Artist/Performance group, Director.
Please don’t forget the following either (Your personal information):
Name:
Title:
Email:
Address:
Country:
Fax:
Organization:
Company/Institution:
Web Page:
…and finally;
Format of music required:
Geographical use of music:
Duration of license required:
Do you need us to send the CD/digital clips to you?
Any other relevant information:
How long should I wait before following up…?
Like so many other busy professionals, Licensing agents are constantly barraged with a slew of requests each and every day. Followup time is very much dependent on circumstances that are beyond your control. A good rule of thumb is to wait at least a week before following up. I know from my own clients that certain companies are much better about following up with potential licensees than others. In order to insure that you are not left in a lurch waiting on final permissions before your mix-down, it is highly recommended that you start this process months before you will actually need the information.
Once we agree on terms, what happens next?
Once terms are agreed upon, the licensor will issue an agreement to you (the licensee). The agreement will outline all of the fine details surrounding the usage including; type of usage, Term (how long), Territory ( where you may show your film), included rights, and price. After carefully reading the agreement, sign two copies and send them along with a check for the usage agreed to. Once the licensor receives the agreement, they will process the check and countersign returning a final copy to you for your files. Keep all legal documents together in a common file for your film. These are often required for entry into film festivals, and will most certainly be required in case anyone ever questions the music contained in your film.
Questions?
If you have any questions regarding music licensing, or any interest in licensing music from Naxos for your upcoming project, please feel free to contact me directly. I am always eager to discuss new and upcoming projects with filmmakers and enjoy helping new producers and filmmakers through the licensing process. I personally represent the Naxos catalog which is filled with thousands of the world’s finest Classical, World, and Jazz recordings. If I can be of assistance to you… I will be my pleasure to help.
Happy Birthday America… your present? is Youtube videos from my latest panel!
Jul 4th
OK, so I know you were expecting something better… but this is the best I can come up with. A Month or so ago, I spoke on a panel at the “Major Orchestra Librarians Association” convention. The Panel was really a “who’s who” of folks from around the industry… here is the panel description:
“From traditional CDs to in-house labels and commercial downloads, the panel
will explore current trends and future possibilities in recordings, licensing and
other issues affecting performance organizations and their librarians
Michael Bronson, Arts Management Consultant and Television Producer
Randall Foster, Licensing and Content Manager, Naxos of America, Inc.
Patrick McGinn, Librarian, Milwaukee Symphony Orchestra
Marc Ostrow, General Manager, Boosey and Hawkes, Inc.
Maurice Russell, Vice President, Business Affairs and Licensing,
Harry Fox Agency
Kazue McGregor, Librarian, Los Angeles Philharmonic, Moderator”
So the folks were kind enough to post video of the panel on Youtube and I thought I would share. Below are highlights featuring Moi and at the bottom of the post is a link to the entire panel. Enjoy America… you deserve it!


